Rent in Islip, NY: Prices & Apartments for Rent
As of October 17, 2026, there are 60 rentals listed in Islip, NY on Redfin, Zillow and ApartmentHomeLiving. Too few listings have a single price and bedroom count to report a reliable median rent.
Updated · 60 listings. Prices are advertised asking rents; check availability on the original listing. How we calculate
Open the Islip rental mapMedian rent in Islip
From listings with a single price and a single bedroom count. Fewer than 20 such listings and we leave the figure out.
- Studio
- —
- 0 listings
- 1 bedroom
- —
- 11 listings
- 2 bedrooms
- —
- 5 listings
- 3+ bedrooms
- —
- 19 listings
Rentals in Islip
See all 60 on the map →
Hawthorne Living
211 Hawthorne Ave, Islip, NY 11722
$2,319 – $3,500 · 1–3 bd · 1,110 sqft
Brookwood at Islip
29 Buffalo Ave, Islip, NY 11751
$2,323 – $2,794 · 1–2 bd · 950 sqft
Brookwood at Islip
29 Buffalo Ave Apt 70, Islip, NY 11751
$2,323 – $2,774 · 1–2 bd
584 Main St Floor 1
584 Main St Floor 1, Islip, NY 11751
$3,000 · 1 bd · 620 sqft
16 Willow Ave Unit 2B
16 Willow Ave Unit 2B, Islip, NY 11751
$3,025 · 1 bd · 900 sqft
102 Moonlight Walk Unit 102
102 Moonlight Walk Unit 102, Islip, NY 11741
$3,030 · 2 bd · 950 sqft
Renting in Islip: common questions
- How many rentals are available in Islip, NY?
- 60 rentals are listed in Islip, NY on Redfin, Zillow and ApartmentHomeLiving as of October 17, 2026, after removing listings that appear on more than one site.
- How are these rent prices calculated?
- We collect active listings from Redfin, Zillow and ApartmentHomeLiving, remove duplicates across sites, and take the median of asking rents for listings with one price and one bedroom count. If fewer than 20 listings qualify for a bedroom size, we leave that figure out. Read the full methodology
Rent in cities near Islip
- Bay Shore, NY1BR $2,415 · 162 · 2 mi
- Deer Park, NY52 · 6 mi
- Babylon, NY1BR $2,700 · 75 · 6 mi
- Sayville, NY52 · 6 mi
- Ocean Beach, NY163 · 6 mi
- West Babylon, NY1BR $2,480 · 80 · 7 mi
- Lindenhurst, NY1BR $2,715 · 74 · 9 mi
- Patchogue, NY67 · 10 mi
- Amityville, NY55 · 11 mi
- Farmingdale, NY71 · 12 mi
- Huntington Station, NY65 · 13 mi
- Northport, NY52 · 14 mi
All cities in New York · Cheapest places to rent in New York · Embed this data