Rent in Bay Shore, NY: Prices & Apartments for Rent
As of October 17, 2026, the median asking rent for a 1-bedroom in Bay Shore, NY is $2,415/month, based on 35 active listings on Redfin, Zillow and ApartmentHomeLiving. 2-bedroom: $3,000 (25 listings).
That is 7% below the New York 1-bedroom median of about $2,600. Nearby, the 1-bedroom median ranges from $2,480 in West Babylon to $2,715 in Lindenhurst.
Updated · 162 listings. Prices are advertised asking rents; check availability on the original listing. How we calculate
Open the Bay Shore rental mapMedian rent in Bay Shore
From listings with a single price and a single bedroom count. Fewer than 20 such listings and we leave the figure out.
- Studio
- —
- 6 listings
- 1 bedroom
- $2,415
- 35 listings
- 2 bedrooms
- $3,000
- 25 listings
- 3+ bedrooms
- —
- 12 listings
Rentals in Bay Shore
See all 162 on the map →
Mid Island Apartments
35 Penataquit Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706
$1,970 – $3,150 · Studio–2 bd · 915 sqft
Brookwood at Bay Shore
99 S Clinton Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706
$2,121 – $2,221 · 1 bd · 522 sqft
Fairfield On The Lake
15 Willowbrook Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706
$2,325 – $2,540 · 1 bd
Fairfield Eastbrook Gardens
327 Brook Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706
$2,415 – $3,025 · 1 bd
Fairfield South At Bay Shore
53 S Clinton Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706
$2,450 – $2,915 · 1–2 bd
Shoregate
143 4th Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706
$2,560 – $6,031 · Studio–3 bd · 1,508 sqft
1731 N Gardiner Dr Apt 6A
1731 N Gardiner Dr Apt 6A, Bay Shore, NY 11706
$2,695 · 2 bd · 625 sqft
1735 N Gardiner Dr #25B
1735 N Gardiner Dr #25B, Bay Shore, NY 11706
$2,950 · 2 bd · 640 sqft
Renting in Bay Shore: common questions
- What is the median rent for a 1-bedroom apartment in Bay Shore, NY?
- As of October 17, 2026, the median asking rent for a 1-bedroom in Bay Shore, NY is $2,415 per month, based on 35 listings with a single price. A 2-bedroom has a median of $3,000.
- How many rentals are available in Bay Shore, NY?
- 162 rentals are listed in Bay Shore, NY on Redfin, Zillow and ApartmentHomeLiving as of October 17, 2026, after removing listings that appear on more than one site.
- How are these rent prices calculated?
- We collect active listings from Redfin, Zillow and ApartmentHomeLiving, remove duplicates across sites, and take the median of asking rents for listings with one price and one bedroom count. If fewer than 20 listings qualify for a bedroom size, we leave that figure out. Read the full methodology
- How much income do I need to rent in Bay Shore, NY?
- Many landlords ask for gross income of at least 3 times the monthly rent. For a median 1-bedroom at $2,415/month, that is about $7,245 a month, or $86,940 a year.
Rent in cities near Bay Shore
- Islip, NY60 · 2 mi
- Babylon, NY1BR $2,700 · 75 · 4 mi
- Deer Park, NY52 · 4 mi
- West Babylon, NY1BR $2,480 · 80 · 5 mi
- Lindenhurst, NY1BR $2,715 · 74 · 7 mi
- Ocean Beach, NY163 · 7 mi
- Sayville, NY52 · 8 mi
- Amityville, NY55 · 9 mi
- Farmingdale, NY71 · 10 mi
- Huntington Station, NY65 · 12 mi
- Patchogue, NY67 · 12 mi
- Northport, NY52 · 13 mi
All cities in New York · Cheapest places to rent in New York · Embed this data